Andre

Breaking mines down into tiers, I think you can make the case for any of those clans grouped together to be higher in their bracket
 
1) Mm - Strongest peak, most impressive F2P full out record, and managed to overcome some stiff competition during their reign.. Had that ability to kick into another gear that other clans just couldn't match
2) Foe - Being a FOE fan boy I really wanted to put them #1, and I think you can make a strong case for it, but the difference for me would probably be Mm had to deal with a lot more competition in F2P than FOE did in P2P. Gods of P2P with great longevity.
 
3) Eop
4) Fatality
 
A month ago I'd probably have Fatality above EoP, this one is also very close but the recent weekend dominance by Eop against them, along with my own personal bias has them just barely above Fi.
 
EoP has the better peak and faced much tougher competition when they were on top (Prime and Peak Mm, prime Foe, even Epidemic in late and early 09/10) while Fi has dominated other periods where there was less to deal with as a top clan. Fi have been better in P2P, and have the full out win vs EoP, so it's really close.
 
5) Epidemic - Top 3 F2P peak right behind Eop/Mm, the first clan to probably piss off Mm and make them kick it to that next gear and were still able to beat them for ~3 weeks, one of the best matched and organized clan for their time... did so in late 2009 and early 2010 when the pure community was at it's competitive peak IMO
6) The Last Pures - One of the greatest matched clans of all time, very mediocre and inconsistent when it came to the wilderness compared to those above.
7) Corrupt Pures - Peaked too early imo, have been open for a long time so that's a bit of a plus but have been mediocre for far too long. Good second tier matched opts game for a long time now
 
 
8) Destructive Pures - Would've probably been in the tier below had they not of gotten a good amount of Epidemic apps, peaked at #3 in both servers when P2P was getting more competitive for MPC clans. Competitive clan in the wilderness for most of their existence.
9) Enemy
10) Devastation - Kind of like DP in that they were really good and competitive in both servers.
 
11) The Hatred
12) Control - Version 1 was very underrated, might've peaked at #3 (?) in F2P for a while there in 2011.. the OSRS version didn't really help nor hurt them as they were polar opposites almost - good in P2P but couldn't really leave their mark in the wilderness or have trips.
13) Intense Redemption
14) Zenith - Had the potential to be higher but I always felt iffy about their leadership. Too many versions of them certainly doesn't help.. they've had 3 closures on OSRS alone
 
15) Redemption - Don't feel confident with their leadership either, have done well in OSRS to remain competitive in both clan wars and the wilderness.
16) Tgg
 
Divinity/Ascendency/Malice/Havoc/Carnage/EF/CPR/Zu etc - Rest of the clans were either too one server sided, or couldn't really do much outside of CWA/PCL

lmfao just shows how broccolied they really are

Was a great experience 
 
#Supremacy 4 a way out

Supremacy vs Trauma matched F2P would be hilarious l0l