I'd say foe's f2p in feb-may when we had active ranks and hype was basically unbeatable, I was amazed at how well we performed in f2p wild, 100+ pulls without signups and everyone would nonstop return for hours. We had no alliance helping us, meanwhile rage would always have vennies, they pm xlpcs and lots of random anti foe people would come in their cape when we fight. P2p was uncontested all these months of the rivalry.
It was a really good 6-7 months of complete dominance, zenith never wanted a fight after we finished killing ly and rage. Our slump has nothing to do with zenith either, just a bunch of drama and basically all our ranks going inactive.